mercedes a class hatchback vs saloon

When will we learn to trust that Mercedes knows what it’s doing when it comes to adding seemingly unnecessary new models to its line-up? When Benz announced that the fourth-generation A-Class would be gaining a saloon version, to be offered alongside the A-Class hatch and the CLA coupe-saloon, the puzzlement was widespread – even in our own office. Why one compact saloon, let alone two, at a time when everybody is going crossover crazy?

But as with similar conundrums throughout the Merc range – CLS vs GT 4 Door, and all those SUVs vs their coupe cousins – the point becomes apparent the moment you drive them.

It’s available with choice of petrol and diesel engines, front- and all-wheel drive and three trim levels, plus the hot AMG A35 version.

Just how different is the A-Class Saloon?

Not very. The structural differences are focused on the back end. The hatch becomes a trunk, and it sticks out further. The roofline curves slightly differently. But see the two A-Classes head-on and you’d struggle to spot the difference. The differences between A and CLA are slightly greater, but they have the same wheelbase, largely the same underpinnings and very similar interiors.

The saloon has slightly less rear headroom than the hatch but significantly more than the CLA, because of the shape of its roof.

A-Class saloon

With the rear seats up, the saloon has the bigger boot: 420 litres against the hatchback’s 370. It’s a long, easily accessed space, but ultimately can’t match the hatch’s seats-down practicality.

All three cars feel very similar from the driver’s seat. The bigger differences are in the back and from the outside. We’re talking about details like the shape of the CLA’s rear seats, or the absence of frames on the CLA’s front door windows. An awful lot comes down to your own styling preferences.

What are your choices?

The saloon is available with a powertrain line-up that’s very similar to the hatchback’s but not identical. The chief divergence comes at the very top end, where the saloon currently peaks with the AMG A35, whereas the five-door gives a choice of A35 and A45.

Excluding the AMG, saloon buyers get a choice of four petrols, with a mix of manual and automatic, and front- and all-wheel drive, and three diesels, all with seven- or eight-speed automatic gearboxes and front-wheel drive.

A-Class saloon side

The saloon skips the hatchback’s most basic trim level, SE, and starts with Sport (17in wheels, LED headlights), before leaping to AMG Line (bodykit, different wheels, more stylish grille, tinted rear glass, sportier seats, flat-bottomed steering wheel) – not to be confused with the high-performance AMG A35, which has its own trim level. The CLA, meanwhile, leapfrogs Sport and treats AMG Line as its entry level, with accordingly higher prices. Still with us?

Prices start just below £27k and proceed steeply northwards to almost £37k, before you start adding extras. (CLA prices span £32k to £38k.)

Leave a Comment